I recently posted about the major overhaul to Chase’s popular luxury credit card, the Sapphire Reserve. The change catching most people’s attention is the higher annual fee.
I wrote that even with the increased annual fee, I am keeping the Sapphire Reserve in my wallet.
I heard from a number of readers who also decided to keep the card despite the increased annual fee.
Just as good, I heard from some readers who applied for the Sapphire Reserve for the first time after reading my post.
I love hearing these types of comments from readers. Keep ’em coming!
Today, I want to share my thoughts on another question that came from multiple readers. The question goes something like this:
My spouse and I both have our own, separate Sapphire Reserve accounts from before we were married. With the higher annual fee, we are wondering if it makes sense to keep both accounts open.
If we closed one account, we could then add that person as an authorized user on the other account.
What do you think?
This is a great question because there’s lots to think and talk about.
Besides maximizing credit card value and minimizing fees, this question also touches on how couples manage their finances together.
While that is an incredibly important conversation, we’ll have to leave it for another day. Today, I’ll simply highlight some of the relevant considerations.
Finally, I love this question because it’s a good reminder that talking about money is not taboo. We all benefit when we discuss how to use money as a tool that works for us, not the other way around.
Let’s get to it.
What changed with the Sapphire Reserve?
The Sapphire Reserve now comes with an annual fee of $795 (up from $550). That is the highest annual fee in the luxury credit card market.
On top of that, the fee for authorized users increased from $75 to $195.
In its press release announcing the revamped card, Chase advertised $2,700 in annual value for cardmembers.
Compared to an annual fee of $795, that sounds like a whole lot of value.
The problem is it takes effort to receive all that value. More than effort, it takes spending. This can get complicated, even with only one card. With two cards, it can be even more challenging.
For a complete description of all of the potential benefits, you can visit the Sapphire Reserve website.
Remember that with all credit cards, the more you spend, the more you earn. That’s true whether you are accumulating points or utilizing shopping or travel credits and other discounts.
This is a good place to emphasize the first rule of responsible credit card usage:
Don’t spend money just to earn rewards. That’s a recipe for financial disaster.
The Sapphire Reserve is no exception to this rule, regardless of whether you have one or two cards in your household.
Before we go further, it’s important to understand what it means to be an authorized user.
What is an authorized user on a credit card?
An authorized user is someone added to the primary account holder’s credit card account. Authorized users typically include spouses, partners or children of the primary cardholder.
The authorized user gets his own physical card, but all spending is tracked on the primary account holder’s account.
Importantly, that means that the primary account holder remains responsible for all payments.
That also means the primary account holder receives all the points earned when the authorized user makes a purchase.

With cards like the Sapphire Reserve, the authorized user gets most of the same perks and benefits as the primary cardholder. Most notably, that includes lounge access and other travel perks.
Not all credit cards offer the same perks for authorized users. Be sure to understand the rules about authorized users for any card you are considering.
Before you add an authorized user to your account, make sure you understand that you are 100% responsible for that person’s spending.
On the flip side, before you become an authorized user, understand that all of your points earned will go the primary account holder.
If either of these restrictions are enough to give you pause about adding or becoming an authorized user, there’s no need read any further.
You should continue to have separate credit card accounts.
And, you should review my post to help you decide whether the Sapphire Reserve is right for each of you on an individual basis.
If you have no problems with adding somebody as an authorized user, read on to find out whether it makes sense in your situation.
What is the actual cost difference for adding an authorized user instead of keeping our accounts separate?
Assuming you are OK with adding or becoming an authorized user, let’s look at what the actual cost is compared to keeping your accounts separate.
Here are the options for couples that currently have two Sapphire Reserve accounts:
- Option 1: Keep both accounts open and pay $1,590 in annual fees.
- Option 2: Close one account, add an authorized user to the open account, and pay $990 in annual fees.
Note: while you don’t have to add an authorized user to your account, I’m assuming you’re reading this post because you are considering it.
If you stopped your analysis here, you’d see that there is a $600 difference if the couple keeps both Sapphire Reserve accounts open.
That’s a lot of money and may lead you to think cancelling one of the cards is the easy decision.
However, just like we explored in my post on why I’m keeping the Sapphire Reserve, there are ways to offset and reduce the annual fee.
You can check out my post if you’re curious how I evaluate and use credit cards.
For today’s purposes, remember that the Sapphire Reserve offers a $300 annual travel credit. The credit gets automatically applied whenever you make a qualifying travel purchase.
It’s safe to assume that anyone willing to pay $795 for a luxury travel card is going to spend at least $300 per year on travel.
The same assumption goes for couples thinking about keeping two Sapphire Reserve cards: they are going to spend at least $600 on travel between the two of them each year.
Applying the $300 travel credit, the total cost for each scenario drops as follows:
- Option 1: Keep both accounts open and pay $990 in total fees. (Each account holder receives a $300 travel credit, reducing the total cost by $600.)
- Option 2: Close one account, add an authorized user, and pay $690 in annual fees.
So, the real question becomes: is it worth an extra $300 annually to keep both Sapphire Reserve accounts open?
When the extra cost of keeping both cards drops from $600 to $300, the decision gets a bit tougher.
You may still be thinking that $300 is too much money to spend each year to have two of the same cards in your household.
Personally, I agree with you.
Below, I’ll show you what my wife and I do instead of having two Sapphire Reserve cards.
However, there are some reasons why it may be beneficial for couples to keep both cards. Let’s look at those reasons now.
Why it might make sense for couples to have two Sapphire Reserve credit cards.
Here are some of the main reasons why it would make sense for a couple to keep two Sapphire Reserve cards.
Trust issues. The bottom line is some couples just don’t trust each other when it comes to spending and paying bills. There’s no shame in that. It’s just a reality.
Like we discussed above, if you find yourself in this situation, it doesn’t make sense to add or become an authorized user. The potential downsides, resentment, and arguments outweigh the $300 in annual savings.
Accounting challenges. When you add an authorized user, all purchases get tracked together on the primary cardholder’s account. If it’s important for you to know who is making each purchase, this can be an accounting nightmare.
Plus, some couples maintain separate bank accounts and pay bills separately. Having all credit card purchases appear on only one person’s account makes it more difficult to figure out who should pay for what.

Business expenses. It’s also not uncommon for lawyers and professionals to use their Sapphire Reserve cards for business purposes and then get reimbursed by their employers.
If that’s the case, it may not make sense for you to blend personal and business expenses on one card. You could use one Sapphire Reserve strictly for business purposes and the other for personal expenses.
Impact on your Credit History. You may not want to close your account because of the potential impact it will have on your credit history. This is particularly important if your Sapphire Reserve is the card you’ve had for the longest time.
While this is a valid concern, there are ways to close your account without having any impact on your credit history whatsoever.
The best thing to do before you close your account is to transfer your available credit line to one of Chase’s other credit cards, like the Freedom Unlimited.
The Freedom Unlimited is the only other credit card I keep in my wallet.
There is no annual fee with the Freedom Unlimited, and it’s the perfect compliment to the Sapphire Reserve.
If you need help with this part, reach out to me on Instagram or LinkedIn, and I’ll walk you through the exact steps.
Sign-up Bonuses and Credits. If you are thinking about getting a Sapphire Reserve, now is the time to do it. Chase is offering its biggest sign-up bonus ever: 125,000 points for new applicants.
Using The Points Guy’s valuation, 125,000 points are currently worth $2,562.50.
Combined with some of these other reasons, these bonus points might make this decision a no-brainer.
Besides the sign-up bonus, the Sapphire Reserve comes with a number of other credits and benefits valued at $2,700 annually.
For a complete description of all of the potential benefits, you can visit the Sapphire Reserve website.
If you and your spouse or partner will independently take advantage of all these perks, then it could be worth it to keep both cards.
In the end, if any one of the above applies to your situation, it may make sense to keep two Sapphire Reserve cards despite the extra $300 annual cost.
My wife and I used to have two Sapphire Reserve cards.
There was a time in my life when I had 10 different credit cards because I wanted to maximize the points I earned on every purchase.
My wife and I each had Sapphire Reserve cards, too.
We did earn a lot of points. But, it was so stressful.
Keeping track of what card to use for every single purchase was complicated. Making sure we paid off each card every month was even harder. In the end, it wasn’t worth it.
We now keep things simple, and I recommend most people do the same.
Today, I only have two credit cards in my wallet: the Sapphire Reserve and the Freedom Unlimited.
I use the Sapphire Reserve for travel (4 points per dollar spent on airlines and hotels) and dining (3 points per dollar).
I use the Freedom Unlimited for everything else. The Freedom Unlimited earns 1.5 points across the board for every purchase. In contrast, the Sapphire Reserve only earns 1 point per dollar spent in non-bonus categories.
Same as me, my wife only carries the Sapphire Reserve and Freedom Unlimited. This way, we can combine points to maximize our rewards.
Together, we still earn plenty of points and our finances are much simpler.
I prefer to have two different cards that offer distinct but complimentary benefits.
If your household is going to keep multiple cards, I suggest having different cards instead of doubling up on the same one. That’s true whether you combine accounts or keep them separate.
That way, you can reap a more diverse set of benefits for a comparable cost.
If you go this route, it’s helpful to keep your credit cards within the same bank (i.e. stick with Chase or stick with American Express) so you can combine points and accumulate rewards faster.
Even if the Freedom Unlimited doesn’t appeal to you, I’d suggest looking at other credit cards within the Chase portfolio that earn Ultimate Rewards points.
For example, my wife and I have the Chase Ink Business Unlimited and the Chase Ink Business Cash for our various rental property businesses.
Each card earns Ultimate Rewards points that we can combine with our Sapphire Reserve.
Let us know in the comments below how you view having two of the same cards in your household.
As always, reach out if I can be of any assistance.